I already know you're super excited about tonight's premieres of Ugly Betty and Grey's Anatomy (starting at 8pm (ET), so I'm taking those out of the running for what I'm going to watch tonight. Clearly, they're already DVRed. And don't worry, recappers Shanna and Joanna will be delivering a full report tomorrow morning.

So, let the games begin. Here's tonight's lineup...

At 8pm (ET): Smallville on the CW and My Name Is Earl on NBC
At 9pm (ET): The Office on NBC and CSI on CBS
At 10pm (ET): New show Big Shots on ABC, Without a Trace on CBS and the 14th season premiere of ER on NBC

*Note: I've seen the pilot of Big Shots, and it's awesome -- just like Sex and the City, but with boys... not that I'm trying to influence your decision!

Cast your vote for which show I should watch and report back on.