American Idol Recap: Cook's Special Recipe for Success
David Cook's not-so-secret recipe calls for mixing it up real smooth-like and surprising us every time.
He's a tantalizer!
This original recipe is what can make him this year's idol! No doubt!
This week, the theme was to choose a song from the year they were born. That brings him back to 1982. Cook gave Michael Jackson some cosmetic surgery unlike he's ever experienced. He took "Billie Jean" to the limit. And it was hot!
Does Cook come up with all of these arrangements himself? Remember his version of Lionel Richie's "Hello." Ummm... hello! Cook is rocking this competition and taking no prisoners. And he has been since his audition.
Syesha Mercado and Michael Johns were two other amazing standouts this week... singing songs from their birth year that made them come alive on the stage!
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: American Idol Recap: Cook's Special Recipe for Success .
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://tvcocktail.ivillage.com/system/mt-tb.cgi/5792




Good to see you give Kristylee props when she does outstanding!
I'm sorry but the girl (Kristy Lee) still doesn't deserve to go on. I feel she used the song last night as a prop to move her on to the next week. It is a beautiful song and she used it for a vote from America. She was pitchy and had a few spots in the song that didn't cut it for me. Rock on to the guys though!!!
Chris is it!
Kristy Lee shouldn't even be this far. She is no where near the talent of both the Davids, Brooke White and Syesha. There is no point in keeping her on when there is no way she will ever win the competition. Meanwhile, each week we all have to be embarassed for her because America keeps her on, but she can't sing well enough to win the competition. I think she knows that a little herself. I guess we will just have to wait and see until America votes next week. GO BROOKE WHITE!!!
Um... hello! Chris is just doing covers that other artists have already covered in the past! That arrangement of Billie Jean was down by Chris Cornell YEARS ago!
He also ripped off covers done by Incubus and Doxology in past episodes.
I'm not saying this kid is untalented, because he is really great, but he shouldn't be getting credit for coming up with these brilliant arrangements when they are not his idea.
The cover he performed wasn't from the year he was born, it was from a few years ago...
The song was from a few years ago. But the original was from the year he was born. Who cares. No one said he was coming up with these songs on his own. Cook is super talented and deserves credit for researching the songs that work for him. I voted for him all night and i will every week until he wins. Someone sounds like they've been bit by the little green monster Patrick.
When I saw the David Cook's Billy Jean again on Video at http://idol-mania.com/american-idol-fan I was impressed. Some are sparking a controversy that David C ripped off musician Chris Cornell's version.
Regardless David Cook was entertaining while David Archuleta's suck up to David Foster was just plain cheesy.
At least Chris is smart enough to look into the songs history.
Michael John's is the hot one. I lust for him! Why isn't anyone talking about him? And why did the judges think that Jason Castro didn't do good? He sounded great. Goose bumps!
I love David Cook! He is my idol!
Gina I agree with you. Michael is great but so is David Cook. I think it will come down to the two of them in the end. Young David has a great voice but he needs to come back in a few years. Time will tell
That girl really does need to keep her clothes on. What was she doing?
p.s. I don't even remember her as a contestant.
Getting excited for tonight! We can't agree on who it's going to be.
I think it's Kristy.
My friend thins Brooke.
My mom thinks Chikezie.
My brother thinks Carly.
My dad just told us to shut up.
I thought the song was supposed to be from the year they were born. Isn't God Bless America older than 1993?
That Kim girl is nasty!
I don't know who wrote this article, but clearly you and every other TV critic in this country is very musically uninformed. David Cook is very smart musically, no doubt, but he is certainly NOT original... I don't get why everyone is giving him so much credit for coming up with these so called original arrangements...Almost everthing the guy has song has been a cover version of the song..not his own arrangement..He's done INCUBUS's hello, DOXOLOGY's Eleanor Rigby, WHITESNAKE's Daytripper, and CHRIS CORNELL's version of Billie Jean. Nothing is wrong with this but he shouldn't be called orginal and a visonary by critics and the judges when he is clearly not. He is just another good singer along with Michael, Carly and others.
This week had some cheesey moments. David A., Chikezie, and Kristy. Simon said Brooke was cheesey last week with here comes the sun dressed in yellow with a yellow sunset background. Come on Kristy just need the red. white and blue clothing and a Large American Flag.
YUCK! I am really surprised Kristy has not gone yet. And for Syesha to be one of the bottom three was Totally wrong.She sang the best she ever sang through out the competition.
Who's ging him credit. I think we are all thinking ON AMERICAN IDOL. It is unique for an American Idol singer to do.
Me anyway.